The Dominican Republic and Haiti: one island riven by an unresolved past

*This article was published in The Guardian in 2013 by Carrie Gibson, but is still relevant today. There is a resurgence right now to deport all “illegals” and major debate on all sides of the issue.

When Haiti was hit by the devastating earthquake in 2010, its island neighbour, the Dominican Republic, rushed to help. It was among the first to send rescue workers, food and water, and also allowed overseas relief agency flights to land at Santo Domingo airport.

But three years on, the goodwill seems to have dissipated and old tensions resurfaced. Just over a week ago the Dominican Republic’s highest court ruled to revoke the citizenship of children of illegal Haitian migrant workers – a measure to be applied to anyone born after 1929, and thus affecting not only migrants’ children, but their grandchildren and, in some cases, even great-grandchildren.

This is the latest legal attack on the rights of Haitians and their descendants; measures in the past few years have included reclassifying migrant workers as “in transit” rather than legal residents. This meant any child born in the Dominican Republic – which had been one basis for citizenship – also needed one Dominican parent, or one who was a legal resident.

The latest ruling could leave thousands who identify themselves as Dominican but may have had a Haitian ancestor facing an uncertain future – already some 40,000 people have been told they will not receive identity documents. Without official papers, it is impossible to access services such as schools or healthcare. Human rights groups and local NGOs have expressed their concern, and the UN will be reviewing this ruling.

Haiti and the Dominican Republic share the island of Hispaniola, where Christopher Columbus established the first European settlement in 1492. Despite their shared history of colonialism and slavery, dictatorship and oppression, a physical and emotional border has long separated them.

The western third of the island was ceded by Spain to France in 1697, and the entire island by 1795. By 1801 the famed former slave General Toussaint Louverture had freed all the slaves on the island and united it under his governorship, though this was short-lived.

In 1808, a group of Dominicans started the war of reconquest to drive out the French and return the eastern part the island to Spanish rule – the west by this point was the republic of Haiti. But by 1822 Haiti had established control of the whole island once more. Indeed, the Dominican Republic gained its independence from Haiti, not Spain, in 1844.

Modern times have been no less complicated. In 1937, Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo – who wore makeup to lighten his skin and was obsessed with “whitening” the predominantly mixed-race island – ordered the massacre of Haitians in border areas, where many worked cultivating sugar. To determine who was Haitian, soldiers with machetes asked dark-skinned people to say the word “perejil”, which is Spanish for parsley. For Creole-speaking Haitians, the “r” sound was difficult to pronounce, and a slip of the tongue became a death sentence. Estimates of the massacre range from 10,000 to 25,000 people killed over the course of a few weeks. And the bitter irony was that Trujillo’s grandmother was Haitian.

Today the border continues to inspire fear. Dominican-born children of Haitian descent number around 210,000, in a nation of 10 million. Haitians have long been migrant workers, with many finding seasonal employment in sugar cane fields or other low-wage work, which has become especially crucial in the aftermath of the earthquake. And, like immigrants elsewhere, they are often blamed for taking jobs. At the same time, racialised fears of “Haitianisation” are still regularly voiced by politicians and sections of the media, though many Dominicans have expressed shock and anger over the court’s decision. But violence is still directed at Haitians; crimes against them often go unreported; and many continue to live in dire poverty.

Deportations of workers who have no chance to appeal are common – the Dominican military reported it sent away some 47,700 Haitians in the past year, up from 21,000 the year before. And now tens of thousands of people who consider themselves Dominicans face a one-way trip to a country where they cannot speak the language, may not have any family, and face extreme economic hardship. The Haitian government said it “strongly disagrees” with the decision and has recalled its ambassador to the Dominican Republic for consultations on the implications of the ruling.

Anti-Haitianism in the Dominican Republic reaches back decades, if not centuries; unacknowledged and institutionalised, it has been manipulated and put to political use. Rather than being united by their shared histories, the two sides of Hispaniola remain riven by an unresolved past. It is not yet clear how this ruling will be turned into policy, but in facing such an uncertain future, these Dominicans also carry with them a heavy burden of the past.


2 thoughts on “Anti-Haitianism

  1. I am a Dominican citizen, I have Hatian friends.
    The problem with the migration and Hatians becoming Dominican citizen is that most Hatians living hear don’t even carry legal papers. Even when they go back to their country they don’t get them. How can you be a citizen of another country if you don’t even “exist” in your own country?

    The DR has a lot of economic problems, not just saying that more than half of the dominican population are unemployed!
    How can we give a job when we don’t even have enough jobs to cover our own population?

    Hatians are decendants of the french, african, and canadian. The richest families from all over the world have the biggest mansions in Haiti, and they don’t help the haitian population to get a job.
    As well as this other countries, where they have a good economy and low rate of unemployment, they should be able to grant citizenship and visa to at least half of the Haitians if they want to help so much.

    Yes, they are complications, but its not a matter of racism, its a matter ot economic issues.

  2. I beg you pardon for my bad english but i can’t keep readding this wrong facts without clarify them. Issues between Dominicans and Haitians has been for years even before our independence. They’re based on our intrincecals diferences: Costums, Religions, Education, Social Behavior. You could note this diferences just watching because it’s on the surface.
    It is very easy have an opinion based on our own realities and just taking on mind our countries laws avoidding to read Dominican foreign laws.
    All countries who critics dominican actions to take out all iligals who lives in this countries, does it from their foreign laws without read the dominican foreign laws. No body can compare this situation based on their personal realities or in their particular foreign laws.
    It’s pretty sure i could go into US iligaly, Stablished a family and rise them there. But if it happens is because the US foreign laws permit it. Dominican laws doesn’t.
    It’s not true the reference of the “Machete law” and the word “Perejil”. In first place, no bady knows exactly how many haitians were killed in the Trujillo’s goverment. No body count them. I don’t know how could refered that number. The “perejil” word was always used as a joke, never as a “identification method”. I’s hard to believe troops were asking one by one, await the answer, and even so the troops reach that amount of people as if they remains seated at the time they were looking this horrible actions. That number is pure fiction!! If you want to have a clear vision of that period read the book “Monarch without Crown” from Euclides Gutierrez Feliz.
    In US, France, Canada, UK, any iligal is deported to his origin country without any hesitation. And that’s a right of those countries. So is our.
    The headline of this articule reflect a false reality. It seems like dominicans can’t see haitian. If you come to Dominican Republic you gonna find Haitians working in airports, in construction, in bildings, farms, as drivers, studding in our universities, rulling business like cars dealer, grocery, car rental, even asking for money in our main streets in the capitol. The very most of them without any papers (no passport, no ID,,nothing.) That’s something you don’t see in US, Canada, France or UK.
    Iligal inmigration is a big problem, not only for Dominican Republic but also for US, UK, Italy, France, Spain, and so many others countries around the world.
    The only thing dominicans wants is to have control on who is comming into our country. When i fly to US or Europe in inmigration take my name, which is in my passport, my address, the purposse of my visit and the time i’m suppose to stay there. That’s control!! And have to be that way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s